Pages

Monday, January 27, 2014

English Premier League 100: Ranking the 100 Best English Premier League Players

 

« Prev
2 of 105
Next »

Method

Method
Shaun Botterill/Getty Images
In ranking our top 100 players for the coming 2013-14 English Premier League season, we produced a method of scoring each player out of 100 in accordance with his position and individual attributes.
We selected the top five attributes critical to each position on the pitch, then weighted those attributes in order of importance to the position.
For example, when it comes to deep-lying forwards, movement between the lines and the ability to link play is far more important than scoring headers, and that's reflected in the formula we created.
Likewise, it's unfair to grade Andy Carroll on the same metric as Robin van Persie, so we created 18 different positions with different criteria to judge. Sweeper keepers like Hugo Lloris have been separated from regular keepers, there are eight types of midfielders and even surging centre-backs have been split from traditional ones.
We won't reveal the full formula and basis for marking, but here's an example of exactly how the anchor defensive midfield role was analysed and graded.

AttributeWeighting (out of 100)
Anticipation/Positioning

How aware is the player? We study his positional tendencies, how well he keeps the line of engagement and how quick he is to react to and pre-empt danger. You don't need to make a tackle/interception if you've cut the danger out before it's even reared its head.
30
Tracking
When his team is in a two versus three or three versus four situation, on the back foot, how well does he cope with midfield runners darting forward? Does he capitulate and get mixed up or track the appropriate man expertly in a Sven Bender-esque manner?
25
Tackling
Exactly what it says on the tin. How clean is the tackle, how does he approach it, how often does he commit fouls and earn yellow cards for poorly executed challenges? Is he forceful or timid?
20
Stamina
When under the cosh, how well does the player cope with switching targets consistently in the face of long spells of possession and pressure? How's his engine—can he get up and down the field all day?
15
 Passing
Anchor midfielders don't have to be flashy passers, but it's still a big part of the game. Does he occasionally play above his station, or simply win the ball and lay it off as per his job description? Does he concentrate and hit short passes cleanly, or make mistakes in dangerous areas?
10

We graded 206 players on our metric to ensure we left no one out, with the top 100 making the official list.
In the event of a tie, we've simply asked, "who would benefit a team more at this moment in time?" and ranked them accordingly.
Load More Stories

No comments:

Post a Comment